Wrong Chat, Right Guy · Chapter 2
Chapter 02 — Wear That One · Oliver
I stood in Finn’s open doorway, holding a hanger in each hand. He was at his desk, calmly sanding down a small block of wood for his folding-chair prototype. A stubborn smear of dried wood glue still coated his left thumb from his afternoon in the kitchen.
Look up. Just look up.
He paused, blew a light dusting of sawdust off the wood, and leaned back. His dark eyes bypassed my face entirely and dropped to the two shirts I was holding out.
"I'm here to collect," I said, stepping into the room and leaning against his wall to project a confidence I didn't feel. "You promised me a dark green corduroy jacket. But since you're officially volunteering your wardrobe, you get to break the tie. Navy or pale grey?"
Finn set the sandpaper down on his desk. He didn't even pretend to mull it over. "The grey."
"Really?" I held up the navy hanger, giving it a little shake. "The navy brings out my eyes. Kit said the grey makes me look like a substitute teacher who gave up."
"The grey fits you better across the shoulders," Finn said. "I noticed when you spilled coffee down the front of yourself the first week. Wear that one."
He remembered that? Three months ago?
Wait. He noticed my shoulders?
"Right," I muttered. I dropped the rejected navy shirt onto his neatly made bed and began unbuttoning my everyday flannel. I put the empty hanger on his bed and changed into the pale grey shirt, watching the buttons. I didn't want to look like I was preening, but I definitely wanted him to watch. I popped the top button open and spent an unnecessary amount of time adjusting the collar.
I smoothed the fabric flat and finally looked back at him. "Are you picking this because you think it's what Jude wants to see on a date?" I asked, aiming for a teasing tone. "Or because it's what you like to see?"
Finn stood up. He crossed the small room to his closet and pulled out the dark green jacket. He turned back, pausing just a foot away from me, the corduroy held loosely in his hands.
"I don't dress people for Jude," he said quietly.
Okay. Wow. That was a direct hit. I opened my mouth, fully prepared to say something brave, when footsteps pounded down the hallway.
"Does anyone have spare hangers?" Kit’s voice preceded him before he appeared in the doorway, a tangle of damp laundry draped over his arm. He stopped dead. His dark eyes flicked from my half-buttoned grey shirt to Finn standing entirely too close. Kit’s mouth curved into a knowing smirk. "Am I interrupting a fashion show, or a very quiet turf war?"
"Just borrowing some armor," I said. I snatched the jacket from Finn’s grip, stepping back to break the tension. I slid my arms into the sleeves. The fit was undeniably broad on me, but the worn corduroy at the elbows gave it a comfortable, lived-in weight. And the scent—cedar, clean laundry soap, and something distinctly Finn—hit me instantly. It was fantastic.
"Some of us don't have time to complain about the drama department tonight," I added, throwing Kit a sharp grin.
"Your loss," Kit said, thoroughly unbothered. He reached past me and swiped the empty plastic hanger from the bed. "Have fun at the arcade. If Jude tries to pay for the terrible beer with tickets, pretend you don't know him." He sauntered off down the hall.
I turned back to Finn. He was watching me adjust the cuffs of his jacket, his hands slipped casually into his pockets. There it was—that faint, dry half-smile tugging at the corner of his mouth.
"Ollie! Eight o'clock!" Jude's voice boomed up the stairwell, vibrating through the floorboards, followed by the heavy thud of his trainers hitting the bottom step. "The Time Crisis machine waits for no man!"
I let out a long sigh, though I couldn't entirely wipe the smile off my face. "Duty calls."
"Win a spider," Finn said, turning back to his desk.
I walked out of the room and headed for the stairs. I was wearing the exact shirt Finn liked, wrapped securely in his favorite jacket, breathing in his scent with every step. It was a massive personal victory. Which made it incredibly annoying that I was walking out the door to go on a date with someone else.