Wrong Chat, Right Guy · Chapter 17
Chapter 17 — Stop Talking About the Chairs · Oliver
The ceramic plates from our evening sandwiches were pushed to the very edge of the small cafe table. The place was crowded, loud with the clatter of cups and the hiss of an espresso machine, but I was entirely focused on the man sitting across from me. I had my sketchbook open between us, a pencil balanced loosely in my fingers. I was trying to project an air of relaxed confidence.
Finn, meanwhile, was staring at the salt shaker as if it were a complex engineering problem.
"That chair will wobble," Finn said, pointing past my shoulder. "Wrong joint for those legs."
"Mine or the chair's?"
He looked down at my knees. Then up much too quickly. "The chair."
It was the first time he'd looked up in three minutes. A heavy lock of his dark hair had fallen forward, shading his eyes. I watched his other hand grip his water glass. His knuckles were bone white. He looked up, gave a quick, tight smile that didn't reach his eyes and vanished almost instantly, then looked right back down at his invisible blueprints.
My pencil stopped. At home, one look from him could make me forget why I'd walked into the kitchen. Here, he couldn't get through a sentence without checking the furniture.
Oh. He was nervous too.
I liked that far more than I should have.
"Finn," I said.
He stopped tracing the table. "Yeah?"
"I like you," I told him, keeping my voice level over the cafe noise. "I really like you. But if you tell me one more thing about load-bearing timber on our first date, I'm going to draw a very unflattering caricature of you."
He blinked. His rigid posture froze.
"Can I sit here?" I pointed to the corner beside him.
He moved his chair to make room. I brought mine around and pushed my sketchbook aside. Our knees brushed, and I deliberately left mine pressed against his. I reached out, covering his white-knuckled grip on the water glass with my hand.
"Stop looking at the imaginary chair," I said softly, turning my hand palm-up beside his glass. "Look at me."
Finn let go of the glass and put his hand in mine. His shoulders dropped. I ran my thumb once across his knuckles. He looked up.
He looked at me. The tight, wrong smile was gone, replaced by a much softer, unguarded expression.
"Sorry," Finn murmured, his thumb brushing slowly over my knuckles. "I just wanted this to go right. I'm... a bit out of practice at sitting across from someone I actually want to be here with."
I had spent all afternoon deciding whether to roll my sleeves up. Apparently he had also been busy being ridiculous. I wanted to tell him. I wanted to look impressive for another ten seconds.
"You're doing brilliant," I said, aiming for a confident, effortless smirk. I shifted my weight, trying to lean casually against the table edge to show him how entirely unbothered I was.
My elbow caught the spine of my sketchbook.
The heavy book snapped shut, violently launching my pencil into the air. It bounced off Finn's empty plate with a sharp clatter, hit my water glass, and rolled off the edge of the table, disappearing under a neighboring booth.
The cafe noise seemed to pause. Finn stared at the empty space on the table.
I groaned, dropping my forehead against my free hand. "Smooth," I muttered into my palm, my face burning hot. "Highly desirable visual creative at work. Please forget that happened."
Finn let out a low, chest-deep laugh. It wasn't his usual dry half-smile; it was a real, bright sound that made his dark eyes crinkle at the corners. He didn't let go of my hand to retrieve the pencil. Instead, he squeezed my fingers, his knee pressing firmly back against mine.
"Very desirable," Finn agreed, his voice rough and teasing. He leaned in closer, his shoulder brushing mine. "Leave the pencil, Oliver. I'm looking at you."
I lifted my head, catching the undeniable amusement in his face. My embarrassment evaporated, leaving behind a rush of pure, dizzying relief. I smiled back.
A woman in the next booth held up my pencil. "One of yours?"
"Unfortunately," I said, reaching for it. Finn was still laughing when I set it beside the sketchbook.
I wanted to draw that face before he put it away again.