← NovelsContents

Wrong Chat, Right Guy · Chapter 21

Chapter 21 — I Was Waiting for You · Oliver

Jude popped the cap off a bottle of cider, raising it toward the ceiling. "To my spectacular radio demo making the student broadcast, and Kit’s callback for the tragedy of the century."

Kit snagged a plastic cup from the counter. "It's a modern drama, Jude, and I have exactly six lines. But I will accept the toast, provided you pour heavy."

A week after our first date, all five of us had something to toast. My portfolio was finally submitted. Elliot had brought his finished short film on his laptop, though Jude was still arguing that a premiere required popcorn.

Elliot passed me a cup. I thanked him. He nodded, then turned back to Jude. I let that be enough.

Finn stood by the fridge in a grey henley, sleeves pushed up his forearms. He caught me looking and lifted his eyebrows.

Yes, you. Come here.

I walked over, slipping past Kit and the mountain of pizza boxes. I caught his sleeve and nodded toward the pantry alcove. Finn set his cup down and followed, catching my hand before I could let go.

He leaned back against the wire pantry shelving, crossing his arms. The dim light caught the sharp line of his jaw. "Did we run out of cider already?"

"I never told you what I actually wished for on my birthday," I said.

Finn’s posture stiffened. He uncrossed his arms, letting his hands fall to his sides. "You wished for a date. The whole house heard you."

"I wished for a date with you," I corrected, stepping directly into his space. "After I sent that message, I came into the kitchen and looked straight at you. Everyone was offering dates. You were gluing a chair. I kept thinking, please put the glue down."

Finn stared at me. The dry humor vanished from his face, replaced by a sudden, intense focus. He reached out and caught my hips, pulling me a half-step closer until my trainers bumped his boots.

"I sat at that table," Finn said, his voice dropping low and rough, "trying to think of something better than the arcade. By the time I had a sentence, you'd said yes to Jude. I should have just asked." He slid his hands up to grip my waist. "What do you want tonight, Oliver?"

"I want to tell them," I said. "Properly. Who I wanted all along."

His thumb stopped at my waist. "I'm right here. You can tell me first."

"You, Finn. I want you."

He smiled, then tried to stop smiling. Failed.

"Tell them, then. I'm not going to move away."

I hooked a finger lightly into his collar and drew him toward me. He came willingly, then stopped just short.

"Your announcement needs work," he said. "A bit quiet."

"I'm saving my voice."

I kissed him before he could answer. His laugh caught against my mouth; his arms came around me. I had meant one quick kiss. Finn clearly hadn't.

"Price! Mercer!" Kit’s voice echoed down the hall, followed by a loud clap. "Are you two foraging for truffles in there? We need the bottle opener!"

I drew back. Finn followed an inch before stopping.

"Truffles?" he murmured.

"Don't. I'll laugh when we go back in."

His smile widened. Too late.

He reached up, brushing a stray light brown curl off my forehead. His fingers lingered warm against my temple for a deliberate second.

I straightened the collar of his shirt, smoothing the crumpled grey fabric flat against his chest. I kept my hand there, feeling the rapid, heavy thump of his heartbeat under my palm.

"Ready?" I asked.

"Lead the way," Finn murmured.

I took his hand and walked back into the kitchen. At the table I loosened my fingers, an old reflex. Finn held on.

Kit looked down at our hands, then up at my face.

"Well," he said. "You found something."

This time I had an answer ready.