← NovelsContents

Wrong Chat, Right Guy · Chapter 12

Chapter 12 — You Remembered That · Oliver

Finn was at the kitchen sink, scraping damp coffee grounds out of the French press. Kit had left for his audition in the maroon shirt. His black coat was still hanging in my room. I hadn't found the words to return it yet. I leaned against the doorframe, watching the sharp line of Finn’s shoulders shift under his dark t-shirt as he tapped the glass against the bin.

I had spent the morning replaying yesterday’s disaster with Kit’s coat. I needed to clear the air, but the question that actually came out of my mouth had been stuck in my throat for two weeks.

"Why didn't you ask?"

Finn stopped tapping the glass. He set the French press down and turned around, resting his wet hands on the metallic edge of the sink. "Ask what?"

"On my birthday." I stepped fully into the kitchen, before I could decide this was a terrible idea. "The group chat blew up. Jude offered the arcade, Kit offered cocktails, Elliot offered dinner. You offered me a jacket." I crossed my arms, forcing myself to hold his gaze. "Why didn't you offer a date?"

Finn looked at me. His expression didn't shut down, but his jaw tightened slightly. "You told me not to."

I frowned, dropping my arms. "I absolutely did not."

"First week here. Jude was making jokes about who would get together first." Finn looked at me. "You said, 'I don't date housemates. If it goes wrong, where am I supposed to eat breakfast?'"

Oh, God. This counter. Jude laughing. Me looking everywhere except at Finn, who'd been standing much too close.

Three months, and he could repeat it word for word.

"You remembered that," I said, my voice dropping.

"You sounded serious." He dried his hands. "Then everyone jumped in on your birthday. You looked like you wanted the floor to open. I didn't want to make it worse."

"Finn." I rubbed the back of my neck, suddenly hyper-aware of how badly I had misread this. "I've been out with Jude. Elliot. Kit. You saw me leave."

"I saw that it evaporated for them," Finn said. He tossed the towel onto the counter and closed the distance between us. He stopped a foot away, his dark eyes fixed firmly on my face. "You asked me for clothes. You went out with them. I thought I had my answer."

Oh.

All those times I'd wanted him to stop me at the door. He'd been watching me walk straight past him.

My face burned. I couldn't look away from him. "It wasn't a rule," I said. "It was me trying to sound like someone who could survive being asked out. Clearly an ambitious performance."

Finn went completely still.

"The breakfast thing was a cover," I added, aiming for a laugh that came out thin. "I was nervous. But when you didn't say anything on my birthday, I thought you just didn't want to."

Finn reached out. He touched my sleeve. I turned my wrist, letting his fingers meet mine. His eyes dropped to our hands.

"I should have asked," Finn said quietly. "I should have checked if the rule still applied."

"You really should have," I said. I looked down at his hand, then back up to his eyes. "I would have wanted you to ask."

His thumb brushed the rough cotton of my sleeve, once. The tension in his shoulders dropped, leaving that familiar, dry half-smile in its place. "So the rule is officially withdrawn?"

"Completely revoked," I said. "You are fully permitted to ruin my breakfast."

Finn let out a short, quiet laugh. It sent a rush of heat straight to my chest. He let go of my sleeve and stepped back, casually sliding his hands into his pockets.

"I'll keep that in mind," Finn said. He walked past me, pausing just at the doorframe to look back. "I'll let you know when I have a plan, Oliver."

He left the kitchen. I stood alone by the sink, rubbing my thumb over the spot on my sleeve where he had held me. No day. No time. I still had no date with him.

But he'd said he had a plan, and I'd managed not to laugh it away. I looked toward the door, hoping he'd forgotten something.