Wrong Chat, Right Guy · Chapter 4
Chapter 04 — Still Awake · Oliver
It was past one in the morning when Jude and I finally stumbled through the front door. I was still laughing about the horrific chili-cheese nachos we’d inhaled in the arcade booth, trying to keep my voice down so we didn't wake the entire house.
"Absolute hazard to public health, those were," Jude whispered loudly, leaning against the newel post at the bottom of the stairs. His boisterous energy had dialed down into a tired, genuine grin. "Happy birthday, Ollie. I'll let you sleep it off, but we should do it again."
"Yeah," I said softly, and realized I meant it. "I'd like that. Goodnight, Jude."
He gave me a two-finger salute and took the stairs two at a time. I stood in the hallway for a second, catching my breath. I was still wearing the pale grey shirt under the borrowed dark green corduroy jacket, the black plastic spider ring still on my left pinky.
I turned toward the kitchen. The light was still on.
Elliot was standing by the fridge, methodically coiling a bright orange audio cable. A strip of white tape on the wire read Early Shoot - Location A. He looked up and gave me a tired nod, completely absorbed in his equipment prep.
Finn was sitting at the wooden table. His folding-chair prototype was pushed entirely to the side, the wood glue capped and abandoned. In front of him sat a mug of tea. He didn't look like he was working. He looked up the second I walked in, his broad shoulders shifting under his dark t-shirt.
"Still awake?" I asked, keeping my voice light.
"Not sleepy," Finn said. His tone was perfectly level.
I rested my fingers against his mug as I passed. Cold.
Had he been waiting? For me?
Don't grin, Oliver. You don't know that.
"How was the arcade?" Elliot asked, dropping his coiled cable into a canvas bag.
"Surprisingly great," I said, looking at Finn but answering Elliot. "Jude didn't even make me pay for the terrible beer. We actually had a really good time."
That was true. Jude had made me laugh all evening. It felt unfair to say it just to see Finn's face. I said it anyway.
Elliot zipped his bag. "Glad you survived. I need four hours of sleep before this shoot. Night."
Elliot took his bag upstairs. Neither of us said anything until his door shut.
I stood across from Finn. He was staring at the chunky black plastic ring on my pinky. I needed to give his jacket back before I lost my nerve. I reached for the top button of the green corduroy, but my fingers were suddenly clumsy. The worn buttonhole clamped tightly around the plastic disc, the thread snagging. I tugged. It stuck fast.
"Stuck," I muttered, wrestling with the fabric.
Finn stood up. He walked around the table and stopped right in front of me. "Let me."
I dropped my hands. Finn reached up, his knuckles brushing against my collarbone. The scent of cedar and laundry soap was suddenly overwhelming, wrapped around me and coming directly from the man standing inches away. He neatly angled the button and slipped it free of the snagged thread.
As his hand dropped, his gaze snagged on my left hand again.
"He got you the spider," Finn noted, his voice very quiet.
"I earned this spider," I countered, flexing my pinky so the cheap plastic legs caught the kitchen light. "Thirty-two tickets at the basketball hoops. Jude just claimed the glory at the counter."
Finn let out a low huff of breath that might have been a laugh. He didn't step back. Tell me to keep the jacket. Just ask me to stay in the kitchen.
Instead, I slipped the corduroy off my shoulders. I immediately wanted it back. I held it out to him. "Thanks for the armor."
Finn took it, his fingers brushing mine. He folded the jacket over his arm, his dark eyes finally lifting to meet mine. "Are you going to see him again?"
My heart hammered against my ribs. I held my ground, tilting my head. "Is that just housemate curiosity, or are you considering making a counter-offer?"
Finn looked at me for a long, quiet moment. The faint, dry half-smile ghosted onto his mouth. "Maybe."
He turned and picked up his cold mug of tea, holding it in his free hand. He glanced back once before leaving. I stood alone by the table, staring at the abandoned wood glue, my thumb tracing the sharp plastic edge of my ridiculous ring.