← NovelsContents

Wrong Chat, Right Guy · Chapter 14

Chapter 14 — Not Choosing Is an Answer · Oliver

I walked into the kitchen at four. Elliot was already at the table, carefully winding a braided audio cable around his hand. He looked up, his shoulders dropping into a relaxed slope the moment he saw me.

"Survived the typography layout?" he asked, tapping the wooden chair beside him.

I sat down, deliberately closing the distance until our knees were an inch apart. "Just barely. The spacing on my title font is a disaster."

Elliot smiled. He reached across the table, his index finger tapping the inside of my wrist. His touch lingered, a quiet, intentional echo of how we’d sat at the Italian restaurant. "I could record you complaining about the lettering," he offered, his tone dropping into that precise, teasing rhythm. "I need a track of ambient despair for my documentary project."

I looked at his hand on my wrist. I remembered the pale blue light of the outdoor cinema washing over his face, the way his shoulder had pressed against mine when we laughed at the terrible foley effects in the park. I almost covered his hand with mine. It would be so easy to sit here another minute before saying it.

He'd already given me days.

I pulled my arm back, resting my hands in my lap.

Elliot’s fingers hovered over the empty table for a fraction of a second. He noticed the retreat immediately. He smoothly lowered his hand and picked up his coiled cable. His smile thinned into a tight, observant line.

"You asked me to figure out what I wanted," I said, forcing myself to meet his eyes.

Elliot set the cable down. He didn't try to touch me again. The playful ease he had coaxed out of me vanished. "I did," he said, his voice entirely level. "And?"

"I'm sorry, Elliot," I told him plainly. "I've liked Finn since I moved in. I was trying to ignore it, but I can't. I can't go out with you again when I'm still caught up with him."

Elliot looked down. He pressed the end of the cable into its loop, missed, and tried again. I had never seen him struggle with that before.

"Right," Elliot said. He put the cable down again. "Since you moved in."

"You were brilliant the other night," I said, hating how much I sounded like I was reading a script. "I wasn't faking anything in the park. Or on the doorstep."

"I know," Elliot replied softly. He pushed his chair back, the wood scraping harshly against the linoleum. "But that doesn't really matter if you were holding out for Finn the entire time."

He stood up.

"I thought I could—"

"Like me enough?"

I couldn't finish it.

"I wasn't asking for forever, Oliver. I thought you wanted to find out with me." He put the cable in his bag. "You already had someone in mind."

I wanted to make some stupid joke about my own terrible judgment. He would usually roll his eyes, and I would know we were all right.

We weren't all right.

"I am sorry," I repeated, leaving the jokes out of it.

Elliot gave me a flat, tired look. He slung his canvas bag over his shoulder. "I'm going to head upstairs, Oliver. I think I need a bit of distance from you for a few days."

"Of course," I said, shrinking back slightly. "I understand."

He walked past my chair. I moved my knee out of his way. A few minutes earlier I'd moved it closer.

His bedroom door shut upstairs.

I took out my phone. Our chat still had the message about Italian coffee. My thumb hovered over it; I wanted to send another apology, something he could answer so this wouldn't be how we'd left it.

He'd asked for a few days. I put the phone away.

Kit's black coat was still in my room. I would have to stop leaving that conversation for tomorrow, too.

For now, I stayed at the table until I could go upstairs without knocking on Elliot's door.